JURIS-----PRUDENCE
That term perfectly applies to jury duty as it is with prudence that one must serve. We must be not only good listeners, but also good comprehenders. Prudently, we must keep our ears open, and, at the same time, close our ears to the judgements that swirl around us and in us.
My first jury trial did not demand the level of intensity and absorption of scientific data that this one did. But what I learned about our system, the process, the interactions, the courts could fill a textbook. In short, I absorbed and LOVED the experience. It started on 9/11 and gave me a way to serve my county, my community and, in essence, my country. It was the best lesson in social studies one could have.
Some thoughts:
1. Life in the court system is not LAW and ORDER which crams in several stories… all solved within an hour. The real court system is bound by protocol, laws, and the wheels of justice turn ever so slowly… one spoke at a time.
2. Picking a jury is painstaking. Many factors enter the process and attorneys are trained to weed out those who may not be impartial.
3. Some potential jurors do not pay attention to the judges' instructions until they are "in the box".
4. Hooray… there is a dress code in our courts that is upheld…at least in Marin County Courthouse. (NO shorts and no hats).
5. The best of judges are a joy to observe. They listen intently and rule fairly and keep the attorneys in line as well as witnesses and they instruct and educate with a commitment to the process that is unfailing.
6. The judge who respects, appreciates and thanks the jury…gets the most out of the jury. Judge Graham was a steller example of the judicial profession.
7. "Reasonable doubt"and "beyond a shadow of a doubt" are different.
8. The defense has to prove nothing… it's the prosecution that must prove GUILT…
9. There is no such thing as 100% except in pregnancy. You either is or you isn't!
10. There isn't a scientist who won't admit to a 1% possibility of error. That doesn't equate to reasonable doubt when all other evidence, both factual and circumstantial, falls into line.
11. What I learned about me is that I am relentlessly hard on drunk drivers with blood alcohol of 0.11% at breathalyzer time even if its 33 minutes after arrest. The likelihood that it could be 0.07% at arrest is overwhelmingly unlikely. I don't want a drunk on the road… period, end of story.
12. I saw jurors who were willing to grant "reasonable doubt" based on 1% possibility to someone that they related to and felt sorry for. (I can't help but wonder if the defendant had been ethnic, young and less educated would they have maintained their belief in reasonable doubt)....
I highly recommend jury duty as an experience that 'gives us something to talk about' (once the judge says you can). It a common bonding experience with anyone who has ever served on a jury and interesting to those who haven't. Did I "work" the jury room? NO, I just did my jury duty.
And what about you? Have you served? susan@susanroane.com